Winter Garden: Episode 2 (END)

Rating: 9/10
Impressions:
Now that’s a rather big quality drop, but at least it isn’t in any of the aspects that actually count. There are still no flaws in the character animation and drawings, though you just have to notice the amount of simple smileys used for faces. I mean, the most noticeable would have to be Puchiko’s band members, who all had a retarded
look. I was surprised that such little effort was put into the concert though, even though it’s still awesome (since I love concerts and performances in anime). This ending in my opinion is slightly too vague, as it doesn’t solve anything, but rather just gives the possibility of Dejiko getting back together with Takurou. And exactly how long must Dejiko and Puchiko return home for? I guess the ending leaves you to wonder about the possible outcomes; though all the happy ones will all end in the same way. It becomes pretty obvious that Aiko is Takurou’s sister by the end, as it can be expected that this guy, who has been portrayed as a nice guy, wouldn’t two-time so guiltlessly and chase after one while he’s with the other.

I am glad Puchiko got some screen time, though for me it still wasn’t enough. Her job at McDonalds is rather hilarious, especially her onlookers, who all sport the same face. If only Winter Garden was three episodes, then the second could have been devoted to Puchiko and her day. I’m sure it would be highly entertaining, well for me at least since she’s my favourite character. I guess this show was made for Christmas, but there’s always the chance there might be a longer series in the future. The show is nice and touching and will probably give people who like shoujo and slice of life a warm and fuzzy feeling. Well that’s just me babbling. Nevertheless, I highly recommend this show to anyone who likes the romance/slice of life genre, as this is quite a fitting Christmas present. Oh and one more thing, there’s a preview of Hidamari Sketch at the end of the show, and judging by the looks of it, I probably won’t be watching. The quality is not as highly as I hoped, and the story already seemed rather boring.

Hidamari Sketch Preview:

Popularity: 11% [?]
2 comments2 Comments so far
Leave a reply
Please use the <spoiler> </spoiler> tags for spoilers.
I’ve noticed you grade anime pretty easily. Something like “Winter Garden” would have gotten a 6.5/10 (F) due to its lack of “complications” and originality. The artwork of the characters itself is somewhat solid, but other than that, I almost fell asleep due to its plainness.
General Question: Why do anime companies make a series if they already know it’s not going to attract a large number of audiences?
I dunno about your last question, but i rate episodes based on how much I enjoy it, not by assessing the production value and whatnot.